3

Books Aren’t and Shouldn’t Be Like Real Life

I remember the first time I attended a lecture on writing memoirs. I was expecting this lecture to tell me all the obvious things, like how to write about sad or unbelievable events and make them seem as realistic as the moment they happened. Except that wasn’t at all what I learned. Regardless of what the lecturer was actually teaching us, it all centered around the same idea—books are not real life. Who wants to read about real life? Who wants fiction mirroring exactly what they do on daily basis that they hate so much because it has no significance except to get them from point A to point B? It’s the things that are important, and the little things that snowball into the important things, that we care about.

For instance, if I told you that I woke up this morning and walked my dog, got ready for work, and then I was in horrendous car accident (I wasn’t, I’m fine), you might wonder why I even started with walking the dog. You actually don’t care about the rest of my life. That’s fine, neither do I, except maybe when my dog does something cute that I can Instagram, but otherwise, this is all just run of the mill stuff. It’s exactly what people are trying to escape when they’re reading books. Now, if I told you I went on a walk with my dog and saw a man in a red mustang staring at me, the very car that eventually comes to hit me after the memory of those creepy eyes haunted me the entire time I got ready for work, THEN the dog and the shower and the color of T-shirt I picked out can take on a whole new meaning.

A lot of you probably think this is so self-explanatory, but let’s apply it to larger things, say your male character. He falls in love with someone, gets his heart broken, and doesn’t learn anything from it. This is the same thing as me not learning anything from walking my dog (I rarely look to see if weird men are following me…though that might change now…). Why would we want to read about your male character? Most of us have had those relationships, get in, get out, some weird stuff happens, but you’re basically the same at the end, except you’re wearing sweat pants more—or less depending on your level of self-worth.

So, I guess what I’m trying to say is that when you’re looking at your story, your plot, your characters, your side characters, you should be asking, is this something that people are going to want to read in order to procrastinate on doing the dishes or cleaning up dog poop? Or am I just writing about a person doing something with no real significance?

I guess I can take out that scene where my character dreams about muffins in the middle of trying to kill his uncle. No, that was really a scene in one of my unfinished novels… Actually, I think it’d be funny if anyone can give me a more insignificant scene they wrote before realizing. Impress me.

3 Responses to Books Aren’t and Shouldn’t Be Like Real Life

  1. D. C. DaCosta says:

    Great article.My \”panel of experts\” (i.e., friends who read my first book) did ask, \”Where is this all going?\” which was a valid question, because the work included a good number of seemingly insignificant episodes that eventually came together to haunt — or teach — the protagonist. Likewise, there were several events that, while appearing potentially important, did not lead where my readers expected, at all.I think we might sum up your point thus: MAKE EVERY WORD COUNT. If I know an author is going to follow this rule, I will stick with him through the mundane parts.

  2. Aonghus Fallon says:

    Dwight Swain cited two examples of poor story-telling – one was very similar to the one you outlined above: a lot of random stuff happens to the mc over the course of a single day, both good and bad, and the good more or less cancels out the bad. For the life of me, I can’t remember the other example. I guess his point was that stories have the appearance of real life, but actually follow a very formal structure?

    Another case in point (albeit in a different way) is the film,’Minority Report’. The film starts out with the question – are the precogs reliable? This question is answered around halfway through the film (no, they’re not). At which juncture – having resolved its issues – the film should end. However, it doesn’t, entailing a new premise, predicament, question etc.

  3. Kevin A. Lewis says:

    As I’ve been using a lot of my time after our local Borders closed catching up on a lot of stuff I didn’t get around to during my 20 years there, I’d gotten used to a certain base skill level which seemed to run consistently throughout all genres, from literary to formulaic pulp mysteries, etc. So when I decided to do my long-deferred ride through the solar system after Andy Weir’s whipsmart THE MARTIAN, I chose a well-known-sci-fi author whose pedigree went all the way back to Omni Magazine (Sound of crickets…Never mind-moving right along) for a stay at his moonbase observatory. What I got was a technically polished account of space travel and life in the future, bound together with character portraiture, dialog and backstory (including a rather painful attempt at a romantic subplot) that read like it had been written by an enthusiastic 7th Grader; not quite bad enough to make me not finish, but my protests were loud and frequent enough to make my wife poke her head into the man cave to see if I was alright. I was, and still am amazed; I thought everybody knew how to do this! This guy’s got about 30 books under his belt and presumably a sizable readership. I suppose we’d better observe a moment of silence here for all the dateless techies who’ve tried to use his stuff as a template for effective social interplay… I still plan to tour the outer planets, but I’m definitely booking a different airline next trip!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>